Oppression and Mismanagement in a Company

Company is a Separate Legal Entity

A company is recognised as a separate legal entity, distinct from its shareholders. Even if it is fully owned by a single person or a group, the company maintains its independent status. This distinction ensures the company can continue existing regardless of changes in ownership.

However, while a company has legal recognition, it is not considered a citizen and cannot claim fundamental rights granted to individuals.

Example

Suppose John and Mary start a bakery and register it as a private limited company (e.g., "Sweet Treats Pvt. Ltd."). The company can enter into contracts, own property, and sue or be sued in its own name. If the company faces a lawsuit, John and Mary’s personal assets are protected, and only the company’s assets are at risk

Corporate Taxation

As a separate legal entity, a company is taxed independently from its owners. Corporate tax rates vary based on the type of company, its turnover, and prevailing tax laws. This separation ensures that individual shareholders are not personally liable for the company's tax obligations, reinforcing financial security and stability.

Example

Tech Innovators Pvt. Ltd." earns ₹2 crores in a financial year. The company pays corporate tax at the applicable rate (e.g., 25% for companies with turnover up to ₹400 crore), separate from the personal income tax liabilities of its shareholders. The shareholders are not personally liable for the company’s tax dues.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Limited Liability

Limited liability protects shareholders by restricting their financial responsibility to the amount they have invested in the company. This means that even if the company faces financial losses or legal claims, the personal assets of shareholders remain secure. This feature makes private limited companies an attractive option for entrepreneurs and investors.

Example

If "Green Energy Pvt. Ltd." takes a loan and fails to repay it, the shareholders are only liable up to the amount unpaid on their shares. Their personal assets, such as their homes or personal savings, cannot be used to settle the company’s debts.

Company has Transferability of Shares

Shares in a company can be transferred freely unless restricted by the company's articles of association. This feature enhances liquidity, allowing investors to buy or sell shares easily.

While shares of public companies are freely transferable, private companies may impose certain restrictions on share transfers to maintain control over ownership.

Example

A shareholder in "Family Foods Pvt. Ltd." wants to transfer shares to her son. She can do so, provided the company’s Articles of Association allow it and the required approvals are obtained. This enables her to pass on ownership without affecting the company’s existence.

Company is a Juristic Person

Under the Companies Act, a company is considered a juristic person, meaning it has legal rights and obligations similar to a natural person. However, an authorised individual must represent it in legal matters, usually a Board of Directors or a specifically empowered Director.

While a company can file lawsuits, it cannot take an oath or serve as a witness in court, as these actions require a natural person.

Example

"Urban Developers Pvt. Ltd." can purchase land, enter into contracts, and hire employees in its own name. It is treated as a legal person, distinct from its shareholders, and can enforce its rights in court through an authorized representative.

Kickstart Your Business Journey Today!

Register your company hassle-free with Razorpay Rize and get expert guidance every step of the way.

Company has Perpetual Succession

A company's existence is independent of changes in ownership or shareholder status. Even if a majority shareholder (owning 99.99% of shares) passes away, the company continues to operate until it is formally wound up. This ensures stability and continuity in business operations.

Example

"Dabur India Ltd." was incorporated in 1884 and has continued to exist and operate despite changes in ownership, management, or the death of shareholders. The company’s existence is not affected by such changes and continues until it is formally dissolved

Common Seal (If Applicable)

A common seal acts as the official signature of the company, used to authenticate important documents like contracts and deeds. While the Companies Act of 2013 has made it optional for private companies, some organisations still choose to adopt it for added authenticity and formal recognition.

Example

"Metro Pvt. Ltd." adopts a common seal as its official signature. When signing a property purchase agreement, the document is stamped with the company’s common seal, signifying its authenticity and approval by the board of directors. While optional, some companies still use it for formal documents

Decree Against Company & Corporate Veil

A company is generally not liable for an employee's wrongful acts unless they occur within the scope of employment. For liability to arise, the wrongful act must be directly linked to business operations rather than simply occurring during work hours.

The "corporate veil" protects shareholders from personal liability, but courts can lift this veil in cases of fraud or misconduct.

Example

An employee of "RapidMove Logistics Pvt. Ltd." causes damage to a client’s goods while making a delivery as part of his job. The client sues the company, not the employee personally. However, if the directors used the company to commit fraud, the court could hold them personally liable by lifting the corporate veil.

Company can Own Property

A company, as a separate legal entity, can own property in its name, and its assets are distinct from those of its members. Members do not have direct ownership over company assets but may have a right to claim remaining assets after the company is wound up.

Example

"TechHive Innovations Pvt. Ltd." purchases office equipment and furniture. These assets are owned by the company itself, not by any individual shareholder or director. If a shareholder leaves, the equipment still belongs to the company.

Company can be Trustee

A company can act as a trustee if its Memorandum of Association (MoA) permits it. The objects clause in the MoA defines the company's ability to function as a trustee. Companies often act as trustees in managing trusts, employee benefit funds, or asset management services, ensuring structured administration of assets.

Example

"SecureTrust Pvt. Ltd." is appointed as the trustee to manage a scholarship fund for underprivileged students. The company manages the fund’s assets and disburses scholarships according to the trust’s rules.

Capacity to Sue and Be Sued

As a separate legal entity, a company has the right to initiate legal proceedings and can also be sued in its own name. This ensures accountability and allows the company to protect its rights, enforce contracts, and address disputes independently of its owners or directors.

Example

"PureWater Solutions Pvt. Ltd." discovers that a supplier has delivered defective water filters. The company files a lawsuit against the supplier in its own name. Similarly, if the company fails to pay its rent, the landlord can sue the company directly.

Importance of Understanding Company Features

Understanding these features is crucial for ensuring legal compliance and making informed business decisions. It helps entrepreneurs, investors, and stakeholders navigate corporate operations effectively while minimising risks. Recognising the legal and financial implications of these features enables better decision-making in establishing and managing a company.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Small Companies?

Small companies, as defined by the Companies Act 2013, are private limited businesses with lower annual revenue compared to regular-sized companies. They follow the same registration process as private limited companies but have distinct financial criteria. To be classified as a small company as per the Companies Act, a business must meet the revised thresholds for paid-up capital and turnover.

The significance of small companies in India's economy cannot be overstated. They contribute to profit generation and job creation, making them essential drivers of economic growth. By providing goods and services to local communities and niche markets, small companies help foster inclusive development across the country.

The New Definition of Small Company

A small company is now defined as a non-public entity as per the Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules, 2022, effective from 15 September 2022, if it meets the following conditions:

• Small company paid-up capital should not exceed ₹4 Crores, or such higher amount specified, which should not exceed ₹10 Crores.
• Small company turnover limit should not exceed ₹40 Crores, or such higher amount specified, which should not exceed ₹100 Crores.

It is important to note that certain companies are excluded from being classified as small companies, even if they meet the above criteria. These include:

• Public companies
• Holding companies
• Subsidiary companies
• Companies registered under Section 8 (non-profit companies)
• Companies governed by any special act

The 2022 amendment significantly broadened the scope for small companies, enhancing their eligibility for benefits and simplifying compliance requirements, thus fostering growth in the small business sector in India.

Earlier Definition of Small Companies 2021

Prior to the 2022 amendment, the definition of small companies underwent changes in 2021. The thresholds for paid-up capital and turnover were revised as follows:

Comparing Small Company New Definition with Old Definitions

The Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules, 2022, have further expanded the scope of small companies by increasing the limits for paid-up share capital and turnover. Here's a comparison of the key changes between the old and new definitions:

The increased thresholds allow more firms to be classified as small companies and avail of the benefits provided under the Companies Act 2013. This expansion is expected to reduce compliance burdens and facilitate ease of doing business for a larger number of small businesses in India.

Benefits of Revised Small Company Definition

Exemption from Preparing Cash Flow Statements

Small companies are not required to include cash flow statements in their financial reports, simplifying their accounting processes.

Simplified Annual Filings

They can prepare and file an abridged annual return, reducing administrative workload.

Fewer Board Meeting Requirements: 

Small companies are mandated to hold only two board meetings per year instead of four, which lessens operational demands.

Impact on Audit Processes

1. Auditors are not required to report on the adequacy of internal financial controls.
2. There is no compulsory rotation of auditors, which can reduce costs and administrative burdens.

Compliance Ease 

A director can sign annual returns in the absence of a company secretary, further streamlining operations.

Reduced Penalties for Non-Compliance: 

This encourages small companies to focus on growth rather than worrying excessively about penalties.

These exemptions and relaxations aim to ease the compliance burden on small companies, allowing them to focus on their core business activities and growth strategies.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Characteristics of a Small Company in India

Small companies in India have distinct characteristics that set them apart from larger enterprises. Some of the key traits include:

Ownership Structure 

Typically, small companies are privately owned entities, often structured as private limited companies, partnerships, or sole proprietorships. This ownership model allows for greater control and flexibility in decision-making but limits access to larger capital investments.

Simplified Compliance 

One of the key advantages of being classified as a small company is the reduced compliance burden. They benefit from exemptions, such as not needing to prepare cash flow statements, simplified annual filings, and fewer requirements for board meetings—only two are mandated per year. These measures significantly alleviate administrative pressures, allowing owners to focus on core business activities.

Auditing Requirements 

Small companies face less stringent auditing requirements. For instance, they are not obligated to rotate auditors or report on the adequacy of internal financial controls, which reduces costs and simplifies financial oversight.

Limited Resources and Workforce

Small companies generally operate with limited resources and a smaller workforce. They often employ fewer staff members, sometimes relying on a single individual or a small team to manage operations. This can lead to agility in decision-making but may also pose challenges in scaling operations or managing increased demand.

Restricted Market Reach

The market reach of small companies is typically confined to local or regional areas. They often serve niche markets or specific community needs, such as convenience stores in rural areas. This limitation can hinder growth opportunities compared to larger firms with broader market access.

How to Register a Small Company as per the Companies Act 2013?

To register a business online as a small company under the Companies Act 2013, follow these steps:

1. Obtain Digital Signature Certificates (DSCs) for all proposed directors and subscribers
2. Reserve the company name by submitting Part-A of the SPICe+ form
3. File Part-B of the SPICe+ form along with required documents (Memorandum of Association (MOA), Articles of Association (AOA), Professional Declaration, Affidavits, Identity and Address Proofs, and Correspondence Address)
4. Pay prescribed fees and stamp duty for the SPICe+ form, MOA, and AOA
5. Obtain the Certificate of Incorporation from the Registrar of Companies (ROC) upon successful review of submitted documents

Matters to be included in the Board's Report for small companies:

• The web address for the Annual Return (if available)
• Number of Board meetings held during the year
• Directors' Responsibility Statement as per Section 134(5)
• Details of any frauds reported by the auditor under Section 143(12), except those reportable to the Central Government
• Explanations or comments on any qualifications, reservations, or adverse remarks in the auditor's report
• Summary of the company's current affairs and business overview
• Financial summary or highlights
• Material changes in the nature of the business after the financial year-end and their impact on the company's financial position
• Changes in directorship during the year
• Significant legal or regulatory orders affecting the company's going concern status or future operations

Synopsis of MCA Notification on Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules 2022

The MCA has issued the Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules, 2022, effective from 15 September 2022. The key amendments include:

1. Rule 2 has been amended by substituting a new clause 2(1)(t), which specifies the revised definition of small companies.
2. The thresholds for paid-up capital and turnover have been increased in the definition of a small company under the Companies Act 2013.

These amendments aim to provide relief to a larger number of businesses by classifying them as small companies and offering them various benefits and exemptions under the Companies Act 2013.

Frequently Asked Questions

Product Mark

A product mark is a kind of trademark used exclusively on goods, helping consumers identify the origin of the product and ensuring its authenticity. It plays a crucial role in distinguishing one business's goods from another, contributing to brand recognition and reputation.

Product marks fall under trademark classes 1 to 34, which categorise various types of goods, including chemicals, machinery, and textiles. For example, the "Nike" logo on shoes is a product mark that signifies the brand's origin and quality. 

Service Mark

A service mark is a trademark used to distinguish one business's services from those offered by others. Unlike product marks, which apply to goods, service marks highlight the origin and quality of services, helping customers identify and trust a particular service provider.

These marks typically fall under trademark classes 35 to 45, covering various services such as advertising, financial services, and hospitality. For instance, the "Taj Hotels" emblem represents a service mark that signifies premium hospitality services. 

Collective Mark

A collective mark is a type of trademark used to identify goods or services offered by members of a group, association, or institution. It ensures that the products or services meet specific quality or ethical standards set by the organisation holding the mark.

These marks distinguish the collective efforts of a group rather than an individual business. For example, the Chartered Accountant (CA) designation in India serves as a collective mark in trademark, representing professionals certified by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI).

Certification Mark

A certification mark is a symbol used to certify that a product meets specific standards related to origin, material, quality, or manufacturing methods. It guarantees that the certified product complies with established benchmarks, regardless of the owner’s business.

Certification mark examples include the "ISI" mark on electrical appliances and the "Agmark" label on food products in India, both of which assure consumers of quality and safety. Such marks are commonly found on food, electronics, and toys.

Shape Mark

A shape mark protects the distinctive shape of a product, enabling consumers to associate it with a specific brand. It ensures that unique designs contributing to a product's identity remain exclusive to the brand. For instance, the iconic contour shape of Coca-Cola bottles and the unique design of Fanta bottles are classic examples of shape marks that enhance brand recognition and trust.

Pattern Mark

A pattern mark protects distinctive designs or patterns used on a product to set it apart from competitors. To qualify, the pattern must be unique and easily recognisable—generic or common patterns are often rejected. For example, the well-known Burberry check pattern on their clothing and accessories is a classic pattern mark that helps identify the brand.

Demonstrating the uniqueness of the pattern is essential for successful registration, as it ensures the design remains exclusive to the brand, reinforcing its identity in the market.

Sound Mark

A sound mark is a unique audio signature linked to a product or service, allowing consumers to identify its origin through sound. It plays a significant role in branding, often used as an audio mnemonic in advertisements. A well-known example in India is the IPL tune, which instantly evokes recognition of the Indian Premier League.

Arbitrary and Fanciful Trademarks

Arbitrary and fanciful trademarks are distinct categories that stand out for their unique qualities. A fanciful mark is a made-up term or word with no prior meaning, making it highly distinctive and easy to register. For example, "Google" and "Kodak" are fanciful marks, as these words were coined specifically for the brands and have no inherent connection to their respective products.

On the other hand, an arbitrary mark uses a commonly known word but has no direct relation to the product or service it represents. "Apple," for instance, is an arbitrary mark since it’s a well-known word but doesn’t link directly to computers or electronics. 

Geographical Indications (GI)

A Geographical Indication (GI) is not a type of trademark but a separate form of intellectual property protection. It denotes a product’s specific geographic origin and assures consumers of its quality or reputation linked to that region. GIs help preserve the uniqueness of products tied to their location. For example, "Darjeeling Tea" and "Banarasi Silk" are GIs that signify the products’ origins and qualities unique to those regions.

How to Choose the Right Type of Trademark?

1. Assess the Nature of Your Product/Service
   
   Determine the characteristics and qualities of your product or service. Understanding its nature helps in choosing the appropriate trademark type. For instance, if your product has a unique shape or design, a shape mark could be suitable. If your service stands out for its quality or reputation, a service mark might be more fitting.

2. Focus on Branding Goals and Industry Standards

Consider your branding goals—whether you aim to build recognition, guarantee quality, or differentiate your offering. Also, take into account industry practices.

For instance, if you're part of a group or association, a collective mark might be more suitable, whereas a certification mark may be necessary for products requiring quality assurance. Ensure that the trademark aligns with your long-term branding strategy.

3. Consult a Trademark Expert if Necessary

If you are uncertain about which trademark suits your business, it’s advisable to consult a trademark expert. They can assess your product or service and guide you on the best trademark type based on legal requirements and market needs. This ensures that your trademark selection is legally sound and provides optimal protection.

Examples of Trademarks in Action

1. Food Industry
   
   Pepsi uses a product mark that consists of its distinctive logo, which is instantly recognisable by its red, white, and blue colour scheme. This trademark is essential in helping customers identify the Pepsi brand in a competitive market filled with various soft drink options. The product mark not only includes the logo but also the unique design of its packaging, ensuring that every Pepsi product stands out on store shelves.

2. Fashion Industry

Louis Vuitton has trademarked its iconic monogram pattern as a pattern mark. This pattern, featuring the “LV” logo repeated across their products, is instantly recognisable worldwide. The distinctive design appears on bags, luggage, and other luxury accessories, making it a signature of high-end fashion.

By using this pattern mark, Louis Vuitton differentiates itself from other brands and maintains its status in the luxury market, ensuring that customers associate the design with quality and exclusivity.

3. Technology Industry
   
   The name Microsoft is a suggestive mark. It combines “microcomputer” and “software,” hinting at its products (software for small computers) without explicitly describing them. Suggestive marks require consumers to make a mental connection between the name and the product or service.

This type of trademark is distinctive while maintaining a subtle association with the brand's offerings, making it a powerful branding tool in the technology sector.

4. Hospitality Industry
   
   Marriott International uses a service mark to represent its brand and distinguish its services in the hospitality industry. The service mark covers not only the name “Marriott” but also its reputation for providing high-quality customer service, luxury, and a wide range of hospitality offerings.
   

From hotels to resorts, Marriott’s service mark assures customers of a consistent experience, helping the brand stand out in the competitive world of hotels and travel.

Frequently Asked Questions