How to Convert a Proprietorship into a Private Limited Company in India

What is Secretarial Audit?

A Secretarial Audit is an independent verification of a company’s compliance with corporate laws, rules, and regulations.

It helps companies to:

• Detect instances of non-compliance early.
• Promote good governance and transparency.
• Ensure that legal and procedural requirements are consistently met.

The audit is conducted by an independent professional, usually a Company Secretary (CS) holding a valid Certificate of Practice issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI).

Secretarial Audit Applicability

Under the Companies Act, 2013, certain classes of companies are required to undergo a Secretarial Audit.

It is mandatory for:

• All Listed Companies.
• All Public Companies with:
  
  • Paid-up Share Capital of ₹50 crore or more, or
  • Turnover of ₹250 crore or more.
• All types of companies (including Private Companies) having outstanding borrowings of ₹100 crore or more from banks or financial institutions.

Secretarial Audit Report

The Secretarial Audit Report is the formal output of the audit process. It:

• Certifies whether the company is in compliance with applicable laws.
• Identifies any governance risks or gaps.
• Highlights areas of non-compliance and recommends corrective actions.

The report is prepared in Form MR-3, submitted to the Board of Directors, and included in the company’s Annual Report. As per Section 204 of the Companies Act, 2013, the audit can only be conducted and the report issued by a:

• Practising Company Secretary (PCS).
• Holding a valid Certificate of Practice from ICSI.

Scope of Secretarial Audit

The scope of a Secretarial Audit is broad and spans multiple laws, including but not limited to:

• Companies Act, 2013
• Securities Laws, including:
  
  • SEBI (LODR) Regulations
  • SEBI Takeover Code
  • SEBI Insider Trading Regulations
  • SEBI Listing Agreement
• Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA)
• Labour Laws
• Environmental Laws
• Industry-specific Regulations
• Secretarial Standards issued by ICSI

Additionally, the Secretarial Auditor also:

• Reviews the company’s systems and processes for compliance.
• Examines the Board structure and its functioning.
• May rely on reports from other professionals (auditors, legal counsel) for certain compliance areas.
  
  

{{comapany-reg-cta}}

Eligibility Criteria for the Appointment of a Secretarial Auditor

To be appointed as a Secretarial Auditor, the individual must:

• Be a qualified Company Secretary (CS) and a member of ICSI.
• Hold a valid Certificate of Practice (CoP) issued by ICSI.
• Have undergone relevant training in corporate governance and compliance.
• Maintain professional ethics and conduct in line with ICSI guidelines.

Only a Practising Company Secretary (PCS) is authorised to conduct and issue a Secretarial Audit Report.

Process of Secretarial Audit

The typical step-by-step process for conducting a Secretarial Audit is:

1. Preparation of a Compliance Checklist:
   Based on applicable laws and regulatory frameworks.
   
   
2. Compliance Verification:
   The auditor examines the company’s records, registers, filings, and processes.
   
   
3. Management Interaction:
   Discusses preliminary findings and areas of concern with management.
   
   
4. Recommendations and Corrective Actions:
   Advises management on how to address any gaps or non-compliance issues.
   
   
5. Preparation of the Final Report (MR-3):
   The auditor formally documents observations and recommendations.
   
   
6. Filing and Disclosure:
   The report is submitted to the Board and included in the Annual Report as required.

Features of Company Secretarial Audit

A Secretarial Audit is distinguished by several key features:

• Independent Audit:
  Conducted by an external Practising Company Secretary.
  
  
• Comprehensive Scope:
  Covers company law, securities law, tax law, labour law, environmental law, and other applicable legal frameworks.
  
  
• Systematic & Evidence-Based:
  Based on a thorough review of records and procedures.
  
  
• Board-Level Reporting:
  Findings and recommendations are directly reported to the Board of Directors.
  
  
• Governance-Focused:
  Designed to strengthen the company’s corporate governance practices.

Punishment for Default Secretarial Audit

Non-compliance with Secretarial Audit provisions carries penalties under:

Section 204(4) of the Companies Act, 2013:

The company, every officer in default, and the PCS (if found guilty) are liable to a fine of up to ₹5 lakh.

Section 448 (False Statements):

• Imprisonment up to 10 years, and/or
• Fine up to ₹10 lakh for making false statements in the audit report.

The Company Secretaries Act, 1980:

Disciplinary action against the Company Secretary may include:

• Suspension or cancellation of the Certificate of Practice.
• Monetary penalties.
• Professional misconduct proceedings.

Objectives of Secretarial Audit

The key objectives of Secretarial Audit are:

• Ensure the company complies with legal and regulatory frameworks.
• Identify non-compliance issues before they become liabilities.
• Promote good corporate governance.
• Protect the interests of stakeholders- investors, employees, customers, and regulators.
• Help management take corrective actions proactively.
• Prevent penalties and legal actions for non-compliance.

Benefits of Secretarial Audit

Conducting a Secretarial Audit offers many advantages:

• Enhances the company’s compliance culture.
• Reduces legal risks and the likelihood of penalties.
• Supports better corporate governance and transparency.
• Increases stakeholder confidence- important for investors and regulators.
• Helps Directors and Management make more informed decisions.
• Facilitates continuous improvement in internal processes and systems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Understanding the Role of a Director

Directors are individuals appointed by shareholders to supervise a company's activities, as guided by the Memorandum of Association (MOA) and Articles of Association (AOA). Since a company is a legal entity and cannot act independently, it functions through its directors. The Board of Directors, composed of these individuals, is responsible for the company's management and decision-making.

In a Private Limited Company, directors hold significant importance. They are tasked with making everyday decisions and overseeing the company's administration. Shareholders rely on directors to manage their investments effectively and ensure the company's growth and success.

Types of Directors of a Company

Directors are categorised into various types based on their roles and responsibilities. Let us take a closer look at each type:

Executive Directors

• Actively involved in the company's daily management.
• Often hold specific executive roles, such as CEO, CFO or COO.
• Responsible for implementing the company's strategies and policies.

Non-Executive Directors

• Do not participate in the company's day-to-day management.
• Provide independent oversight to the company's board and management.
• Offer valuable insights and advice based on their expertise and experience.

Independent Directors

• A subset of non-executive directors with no financial or other vested interests in the company apart from their role as directors.
• Primary responsibility is to safeguard the interests of the company's shareholders.
• Ensure transparency and accountability in the company's operations.

Nominee Directors

• Appointed by third-party authorities or the Government to tackle mismanagement and misconduct.
• Represent the interests of the appointing authority.
• Monitor the company's activities and report any irregularities.

Appointment of Director to Private Limited Company

Specific requirements must be met when appointing directors in a Private Limited Company, these are:

• The maximum directors in a private company is 15. 
• The minimum directors in a private company is 2.
• The limit of 15 directors can be exceeded by appointing additional directors through a special resolution with the support of 75% or more shareholders.
• The appointment of directors must be in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act 2013.

Provisions of the Companies Act, 2013

The Companies Act 2013 includes several key provisions related to the appointment and roles of directors:

• Section 149: Details mandatory requirements, such as having a certain number of directors, including a female director and a resident director.
• Section 152: Specifies the process for appointing directors at the company's general meeting and mandates the use of the Director Identification Number (DIN).
• Section 161: Provides guidelines for appointing additional, alternate and nominee directors by the Board.
• Section 164: Lists the disqualifications for becoming a director, ensuring that only eligible individuals are appointed to the board.

By adhering to these provisions, companies can establish a well-structured and compliant board of directors.

Reasons for Adding or Changing Directors in a Company

There are several reasons why a company may choose to appoint new directors/board of directors or change its existing board composition:

1. Introducing New Talent: As a company grows, it may become necessary to bring new talent to the board to address new challenges and requirements that come with expansion.
2. Preventing Ownership Dilution: By appointing additional directors, shareholders can delegate more operational responsibilities without relinquishing strategic control.
3. Addressing Inefficiency of Current Directors: A company may appoint new directors to maintain efficiency if existing directors are underperforming due to personal issues.
4. Complying with Statutory Requirements: Companies must maintain a specific number of directors according to the Companies Act 2013. They must promptly appoint new directors to comply with legal requirements if the number falls below the minimum.

Eligibility to Be A Director in a Company

To be eligible for appointment as a director, an individual must meet the following criteria:

• Be at least 18 years old, as minors are not permitted to hold the director position.
• Not be disqualified under the provisions of the Company Act 2013, which include:
  
  • Being an undischarged insolvent
  • Having been convicted of an offence involving moral turpitude
  • Having been convicted of an offence under the Companies Act 2013
  • Having been disqualified by an order of a court or tribunal
• Have mutual consent from the Board of Directors, shareholders and the individual being considered for the directorship.

It is crucial to ensure that the prospective director meets these eligibility criteria before proceeding with the appointment process.

Documents for Director Appointment

When appointing a director, the following documents are required:

1. PAN card
2. Identity proof (Voter ID, driver's license, Aadhaar card, etc.)
3. Residence proof (utility bills, rental agreement, etc.)
4. Recent passport-sized photograph
5. Digital Signature Certificate (DSC)

Procedure for Appointing/Add a Director to a Company

The process of appointing a director involves several key steps:

1. Reviewing the Articles of Association (AOA)

The first step is to review the company's Articles of Association (AOA) to ensure that it includes a clause permitting the appointment or addition of directors. If the current AOA lacks such a provision, it should be amended to include one before proceeding with the director's appointment.

2. Conducting a General Meeting for Director Appointment

The company must formally appoint a director by passing a resolution in a general meeting, either during an Annual General Meeting (AGM) or an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM). 

To arrange an EGM, the company must conduct a board meeting to pass a resolution for holding the EGM. The resolution to appoint the director must be filed in Form MGT-14 with the Registrar of Companies within 30 days.

3. Applying for Director Identification Number (DIN) & Digital Signature Certificate (DSC)

The individual selected for directorship must apply for a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) and a Director Identification Number (DIN) if they do not already possess these. After obtaining the DIN, the prospective director must provide the company with their DIN along with a declaration affirming that they are not disqualified from being a director.

4. Obtaining Consent from the Prospective Director – Form DIR-2

The individual proposed for directorship must express their consent to serve in this role by submitting Form DIR-2, a formal consent to act as a director. An individual can only be appointed as a company director by explicitly giving their consent. This step is crucial to ensure that the prospective director is willing to take on the responsibilities associated with the position.

5. Issuing a Letter of Appointment to the Director

After obtaining consent from the prospective director, the company should issue a formal Letter of Appointment. This director appointment should detail the terms and conditions of the appointment, including the director's roles, responsibilities and any remuneration or salary. The Letter of Appointment serves as a legal document that outlines the expectations and obligations of both the company and the director.

6. Filing Forms DIR-2 and DIR-12 with the ROC

Once the resolution for the appointment of a director is passed and the individual has submitted Form DIR-2, the company can officially appoint them as a director. 

The company must file both Form DIR-2 and Form DIR-12 (detailing the particulars of the director's appointment) with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) within 30 days of the director's appointment. Failing to file these forms within the prescribed time frame can result in penalties and legal complications.

7. Filing Amendment Applications with GST and Tax Authorities

After appointing a new director, the company must file the necessary applications to update the director's details with various regulatory authorities, including the GST Network (GSTN) and other relevant certificates, to reflect the change in directorship. This step ensures that the company remains compliant with all legal and regulatory requirements related to its directors.

Frequently Asked Questions:

What is a Limited Liability Partnership?

A Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) is a hybrid business structure that incorporates elements of both partnerships and corporations. It is a separate legal entity, distinct from its partners, and offers limited liability protection to its members. In an LLP, the partners are shielded from personal liability for the debts and obligations of the partnership, provided they have not engaged in any wrongful or negligent acts.

In India, LLPs are governed by the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008. This act provides a comprehensive framework for the formation, operation, and dissolution of LLPs, ensuring transparency and ease of doing business.

Features of LLP

Before diving into the advantages and disadvantages of an LLP, let's explore its key features:

1. Separate Legal Entity: An LLP is a distinct legal entity, separate from its partners. It can enter into contracts, own assets, and sue or be sued in its own name.
   
2. Limited Liability: The liability of partners in an LLP is limited to their agreed contribution to the partnership. Personal assets of the partners are protected, unlike in a general partnership where partners have unlimited liability.
   
3. Perpetual Succession: The existence of an LLP is not affected by the entry or exit of partners. It has perpetual succession, meaning it can continue to operate even if the partners change over time.
   
4. Flexibility in Management: The rights and duties of partners in an LLP are governed by the LLP agreement. This allows for flexibility in management structure and decision-making processes.
   
5. Minimal Compliance Requirements: LLPs have fewer compliance requirements compared to companies. Small LLPs are not subject to mandatory audits, reducing the administrative burden.
   
6. Ease of Ownership Transfer: Ownership in an LLP can be easily transferred through the amendment of the LLP agreement, without the need for extensive legal formalities.
   

LLP Advantages

Now, let's explore the key LLP benefits that make this structure an attractive choice for businesses:

No Requirement of Minimum Contribution

One of the significant advantages of Limited Liability Partnership is that there is no mandatory minimum capital contribution required from partners. This makes it an ideal option for startups and small businesses that may have limited funds to invest initially. Partners can decide on their capital contributions based on their mutual agreement and business requirements.

No Limit on Owners of the Business

Unlike private limited companies, which have a cap on the number of shareholders, an LLP allows for an unlimited number of partners. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for businesses looking to scale or bring in multiple partners with diverse expertise. The absence of ownership restrictions enables LLPs to accommodate growth and expansion plans effectively.

Lower Registration Cost

Compared to incorporating a private limited company, LLP registration is more cost-effective. The registration process involves fewer formalities and documentation, resulting in lower professional fees and statutory charges. This cost advantage is especially valuable for startups and small businesses operating on tight budgets.

No Requirement of Compulsory Audit

Small LLPs, with a turnover below a specified threshold or contribution below a certain limit, are exempt from mandatory audits. This exemption reduces the compliance burden and saves on audit-related expenses. However, LLPs can still choose to conduct voluntary audits to maintain financial transparency and integrity.

Taxation Aspect on LLP

LLPs enjoy several tax benefits that make them an attractive choice from a taxation perspective. Unlike companies, LLPs are not subject to Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) when distributing profits to partners. This exemption eliminates the double taxation of profits, making LLPs more tax-efficient.

Furthermore, LLPs are taxed at a lower rate compared to corporations. The income of an LLP is taxed at a flat rate of 30%, along with applicable surcharges and cess. This lower tax burden can result in significant savings for the business.

Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) Not Applicable

As mentioned earlier, one of the significant LLP benefits is the exemption from Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT). In contrast, companies are required to pay DDT when distributing profits to shareholders. The absence of DDT in LLPs allows for more efficient profit distribution and enhances the overall financial attractiveness of the structure.

LLP Disadvantages

While LLPs offer numerous advantages, it's essential to consider the potential drawbacks as well. Let's explore the key disadvantages of an LLP:

Penalty for Non-Compliance

LLPs are required to comply with annual filing requirements, even if there is no business activity. Failure to file the necessary forms, such as Form 8 or Form 11, results in a daily penalty of Rs.100 per form, with no upper limit. This penalty can accumulate significantly over time, leading to substantial financial liabilities.

In contrast, proprietorships and partnership firms do not face such strict filing requirements and penalties for non-compliance. It is crucial for LLPs to maintain timely compliance to avoid incurring hefty penalties.

Inability to Have Equity Investment

Unlike private limited companies, LLPs cannot raise equity investment by issuing shares. This limitation can be a significant drawback for businesses seeking external funding to fuel growth and expansion. Venture capitalists and investors typically prefer equity-based investment models, which are not available in the LLP structure.

The inability to have equity investment can restrict the growth potential of LLPs, especially those requiring substantial capital infusion. LLPs may have to rely on alternative funding sources, such as loans or partner contributions, which may not always be sufficient or readily available.

Higher Income Tax Rate

While LLPs enjoy a lower tax rate compared to corporations, it is still higher than the tax rates applicable to certain private limited companies. LLPs are taxed at a flat rate of 30% on their profits, along with applicable surcharges and cess. This higher tax rate can be a disadvantage for businesses looking to minimise their tax liability.

Moreover, LLPs are not eligible for certain tax benefits available to startups and small businesses. For instance, startups registered as private limited companies can avail of tax exemptions and incentives under various government schemes. LLPs, however, do not qualify for such benefits, which can impact their overall tax efficiency.

Conclusion

The Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) structure offers a unique blend of LLP benefits, combining the limited liability protection of a company with the flexibility of a partnership. It provides entrepreneurs and professionals with an attractive option to structure their business, especially for startups, small businesses, and professional services firms.

However, it is crucial to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of an LLP carefully before making a decision. While LLPs offer lower registration costs, exemption from mandatory audits, and tax advantages, they also come with potential drawbacks such as penalties for non-compliance, inability to have equity investment, and higher income tax rates compared to certain private limited companies.

Ultimately, the suitability of an LLP depends on the specific needs, goals, and nature of your business. It is advisable to consult with legal and financial experts to assess whether an LLP aligns with your business objectives and to ensure compliance with the relevant regulations.

By understanding the advantages and disadvantages of an LLP, you can make an informed decision and structure your business in a way that maximizes its potential for growth and success.

Frequently Asked Questions