What is a Foreign Company in India?

What is the Winding Up of a Company?

Winding up a company refers to the legal process of closing its operations permanently. It involves selling the company's assets, settling its debts and liabilities, and distributing any remaining surplus among shareholders according to their rights. Once the process is complete, the company is dissolved and ceases to exist as a legal entity. Winding up may be voluntary, initiated by members or creditors, or compulsory, ordered by a court.

The main reasons for winding up a company include:

• Ceasing the company's operations
• Collecting the company's assets
• Paying off the company's debts and liabilities
• Distributing any remaining assets to the members

The main reasons for winding up a company include:

• Inability to pay debts (insolvency)
• Completion of the purpose for which the company was formed
• Expiry of the period fixed for the duration of the company
• The passing of a special resolution by the members to wind up the company

Key Aspects of Winding Up of a Company

The winding up of a company involves several key aspects that need to be considered:

1.  Appointment of Liquidator

A liquidator is a person or entity responsible for managing the winding-up process of a company, including selling assets, settling liabilities, and distributing remaining funds to stakeholders. A liquidator is appointed to manage the winding up process. He is appointed by members or creditors in voluntary winding up or by the court in compulsory winding up. 

2.  Realisation of Assets

The liquidator takes possession of all the company's assets and realises them into cash. This may involve selling the company's property, plant and equipment, collecting debts from debtors, and recovering any unpaid capital from the contributors.

3.  Payment of Liabilities

The liquidator settles all the company's liabilities, including debts owed to creditors, outstanding taxes and employee dues. The order of priority for payment is fixed by law, with secured creditors being paid first, followed by unsecured creditors and members.

4. Distribution of Surplus

After settling all the liabilities, surplus assets are distributed among the members in proportion to their shareholding. Preference shareholders are paid first, including any arrears, as per their rights. Once their claims are fully settled, the remaining surplus is allocated to equity shareholders in proportion to their shareholding. This process adheres to the company’s articles and legal requirements, ensuring an equitable distribution.

5. Dissolution of Company

Once the winding up process is complete, the liquidator submits a final report to the Tribunal or the ROC. The Tribunal then orders the dissolution of the company, and its name is struck off from the register of companies.

Types of Winding Up

There are three main modes of winding up of a company under the Companies Act 2013:

1. Compulsory Winding Up of a Company (By the Tribunal)
2. Voluntary Winding Up of a Company

a) Members' Voluntary Winding Up

b) Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up

3. Winding Up Subject to the Supervision of the Tribunal

Let us discuss each of these types in detail.

1. Compulsory Winding Up (By the Court)

Compulsory winding up of a company is when a company is wound up by an order of a court or tribunal. This is also known as "winding up by the court". The court may order a company to be wound up on various grounds specified in Section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956 (now governed by Chapter XX of the Companies Act, 2013).

Compulsory winding up of a company is initiated by a petition filed before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) by:

• The company itself
• The company's creditors
• The company's contributors
• The Registrar of Companies
• Any person authorised by the Central Government

The grounds for compulsory winding up include:

• Inability to pay debts
• Acting against the sovereignty and integrity of India
• Conducting affairs in a fraudulent manner
• Failure to file financial statements or annual returns for five consecutive years
• The Tribunal is of the opinion that it is just and equitable to wind up the company

If the NCLT is satisfied that a prima facie case for winding up is made out, it admits the petition, appoints an official liquidator and makes an order for winding up.

2. Voluntary winding up of a company

Voluntary winding up is when a company is wound up by its members or creditors without the intervention of a court or tribunal. Voluntary winding up is initiated by the company itself by passing a special resolution in a general meeting. There are two types of voluntary winding up:

1. Members' Voluntary Winding Up

This occurs when the company is solvent and can pay its debts in full. A declaration of solvency is made by a majority of the directors, stating that they have made an inquiry into the company's affairs and believe that the company has no debts or will be able to pay its debts in full within three years from the commencement of the winding up.

2.  Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up: 

This occurs when the company is insolvent and unable to pay its debts in full. No declaration of solvency is made in this case. The creditors play a greater role in this type of winding up compared to a members' voluntary winding up.

In a voluntary winding up, the company appoints a liquidator in a general meeting to conduct the winding up proceedings.

3. Winding Up Subject to the Supervision of the Court

A voluntary winding up (whether members' or creditors') may be converted into a winding up by the Tribunal if the Tribunal is of the opinion that the company's affairs are being conducted in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the public or the company.

In such cases, the Tribunal may order that the voluntary winding up shall continue but subject to the supervision of the Tribunal. The Tribunal may appoint an additional liquidator to conduct the winding up along with the liquidator appointed by the company.

Winding Up a Company Process

The procedure for winding up of a company in India depends on the mode of winding up. Here is a step-by-step procedure for compulsory winding up of a company in India and voluntary winding up:

The process of winding up of a company in India is complex and involves several legal formalities. It is advisable to seek the assistance of a professional (such as a company secretary or a lawyer) to ensure compliance with all the requirements.

Example of Winding up of a Company

One notable example of the winding up of a company in India is the case of Kingfisher Airlines Limited. Kingfisher Airlines was a prominent Indian airline that ceased operations in 2012 due to financial difficulties and mounting debts.

In 2016, the Karnataka High Court ordered the winding up of the company on a petition filed by the Airports Authority of India, which was one of the company's creditors. The court appointed an Official Liquidator to take charge of the company's assets and manage the winding up process.

The liquidator faced several challenges in the winding up process, including the recovery of dues from the company's debtors and the sale of its assets. The company had a fleet of aircraft and other assets, which had to be valued and sold to pay off the creditors.

One of the major issues in the winding up of Kingfisher Airlines was the recovery of dues from its promoter, Vijay Mallya. Mallya had given personal guarantees for some of the loans taken by the company, and the creditors sought to recover these dues from him. However, Mallya fled to the UK, and the Indian authorities have been trying to extradite him to face charges of fraud and money laundering.

The winding up process of Kingfisher Airlines is still ongoing, and the liquidator is working to realise the company's assets and settle its liabilities. The case highlights the challenges involved in the winding up of a large and complex company with multiple stakeholders and legal issues.

The Kingfisher Airlines case also underscores the importance of timely action by creditors in the event of default by a company. Many of the company's creditors, including banks and airports, had allowed the debts to accumulate for several years before initiating legal action. This delay made it more difficult to recover the dues and increased the losses for the creditors.

In conclusion, the winding up of Kingfisher Airlines is a cautionary tale for companies and creditors alike. It highlights the need for effective risk management, timely action in case of default, and the importance of following due process in the winding-up of a company.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the winding up is a legal process of  liquidating a company's assets, settling of liabilities and distributing surplus to its members. It is a complex process that requires careful planning and execution, and the guidance of professional advisors. 

There are three modes in winding up under companies act 2013: compulsory winding up by the Tribunal, voluntary winding up by the members or creditors and winding up under the Tribunal's supervision. 

These modes of winding up have specific requirements and procedures. Proper planning and professional guidance can help minimise the impact on stakeholders like creditors, employees and members, ensuring a smoother and compliant winding-up process.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Equity Dilution?

Equity dilution refers to the reduction in existing shareholders’ ownership percentage due to the issuance of new shares. Although it doesn't necessarily mean a loss in actual monetary value, it does mean reduced voting power, ownership stake, and potential control over the company.

For example, if a founder owns 50% of a company before a funding round and 40% after new shares are issued to investors, the 10% drop is equity dilution.

Causes of Equity Dilution in India

Several scenarios in India lead to equity dilution:

• Fundraising through equity: When a company raises capital by issuing new shares to investors (angel, VC, PE).
• ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans): Issuing shares to employees for retention and motivation.
• Convertible instruments: When convertible debentures or notes convert to equity.
• Mergers and acquisitions: New shares issued as part of a transaction.
• Bonus or rights issues: Depending on the structure, these can also dilute holdings if not proportionally subscribed.

Impact of Equity Dilution

Dilution can affect stakeholders in various ways:

• Founders: Loss of control or voting power if too much equity is given away early.
• Investors: Reduced ownership percentages, which may affect decision-making influence.
• Employees: If ESOPs are diluted too often, their potential upside gets reduced.
• Company valuation: Though dilution reduces percentage ownership, it can lead to growth and higher valuations, offsetting the effect in monetary terms.

How Does Share Dilution Happen?

Share dilution occurs when a company issues additional shares, reducing the ownership percentage of existing shareholders. While the total number of shares increases, each existing shareholder’s slice of the pie becomes smaller — unless they participate in the new issue.

Here are the most common ways share dilution happens in India:

1. Fundraising (Equity Rounds)

During seed, Series A, or later funding rounds, new investors are issued fresh equity. To accommodate them, the company increases its authorised and paid-up share capital, diluting the percentage held by existing shareholders.

Example:
A founder owns 100% of a startup with 1,00,000 shares. After raising funds from investors who are issuing 50,000 new shares, the founder’s ownership drops to 66.67%.

2. Issuing ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans)

Startups often set aside 5–15% of their cap table for ESOPs to attract and retain top talent. These options, once vested and exercised, convert into shares — reducing the percentage stake of other shareholders.

3. Conversion of Convertible Instruments

Instruments like convertible notes, SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity), or CCDs (Compulsorily Convertible Debentures) convert into equity at a future date. When they convert, new shares are issued, which dilute existing ownership.

4. Mergers or Acquisitions

In some mergers or acquisitions, equity may be offered as part of the consideration to the merging entity or its shareholders. This leads to the issuance of new shares and causes dilution.

5. Bonus Shares to Select Stakeholders

Occasionally, a company might issue bonus shares to certain shareholders or employees as incentives, which can result in uneven dilution.

Reasons for Equity Dilution

• Capital infusion: To fund growth, R&D, hiring, marketing, etc.
• Strategic partnerships: Issuing equity to partners or advisors.
• Debt conversion: Debt turning into equity through convertible notes.
• Regulatory compliance: SEBI regulations may require public companies to maintain a certain free float, triggering new issuance.

Managing Equity Dilution in India

Equity dilution is inevitable as your startup grows — but managing it smartly can protect both your control and long-term value. Indian founders must understand the tools, strategies, and legal frameworks available to reduce unnecessary dilution and align all stakeholders.

1. Plan Your Cap Table Early

Create a 5–7 year cap table projection. Visualise future funding rounds, ESOP pools, convertible instruments, and expected dilution at each stage.

2. Raise What You Need, Not What You Can

Avoid over-raising in early rounds. Each round of funding comes at the cost of equity. Only raise what’s required to hit the next set of milestones.

3. Negotiate Better Valuations

Valuation is key to how much equity you give up. Strengthen your fundamentals, traction, and pitch to negotiate higher valuations, thus minimising dilution per rupee raised.

4. Use Convertible Instruments Strategically

Instruments like SAFE notes or CCDs can delay dilution until a priced round. Use them in early or bridge rounds to preserve equity while bringing in capital.

5. Be Thoughtful with ESOP Allocation

ESOPs are critical to building a strong team, but don’t over-allocate too early. Start with a lean pool (5–10%) and expand as your team grows and funding allows.

6. Include Anti-Dilution Provisions (If You're an Investor or Co-Founder)

While often investor-friendly, certain anti-dilution clauses can protect your equity in down rounds. Founders should understand these clauses and negotiate fair terms.

7. Consider Non-Dilutive Capital

Explore grants, government schemes (like Startup India Seed Fund, MeitY TIDE, or NIDHI), or revenue-based financing. These options offer capital with no equity dilution.

8. Maintain Founder Alignment

If co-founders have significantly unequal stakes, align expectations early. Future dilution can compound tensions if not addressed at the start.

How Shareholders Can Handle Equity Dilution?

• Pre-emptive rights: Ensure agreements include rights to participate in future rounds to maintain shareholding.
• Anti-dilution clauses: Particularly for investors, these can protect them from value dilution in down rounds.
• Monitor ESOP pools: Oversized ESOP pools dilute all shareholders.
• Regular cap table reviews: Stay updated to avoid surprises in ownership shifts.

Conclusion

Equity dilution is a natural part of a growing business, especially in India's thriving startup and investment landscape. While it may seem negative on the surface, it often enables access to capital, talent, and partnerships that fuel long-term value creation. 

The key lies in understanding, planning, and strategically managing dilution to protect stakeholder interests while supporting the company’s growth.

‍

What is an LC (Letter of Credit)?

A Letter of Credit (LC) is a document issued by a bank that guarantees payment to a seller on behalf of a buyer, provided that certain conditions are met. This financial instrument ensures payment security and mitigates risks associated with cross-border transactions. The issuance of an LC involves specific conditions, like the submission of required documents, which the bank reviews before releasing funds. It provides bank guarantees and incurs fees that are essential for its operation.

Examples of Letters of Credit

International Trade Example: A U.S. company wants to buy machinery from an Indian exporter. The U.S. company requests its bank to issue an LC to the Indian exporter. Once the exporter ships the machinery and presents the required documents to their bank, they receive payment from the issuing bank, ensuring trust and mitigating payment risk.

Domestic Transaction Example: A large retail chain uses an LC to purchase inventory from a local supplier. The LC guarantees that the supplier will receive payment as soon as they fulfill the delivery conditions outlined in the agreement.

Basics of a Letter of Credit Transaction

Applicant

The buyer who requests the LC from their bank. They initiate the process by applying for the LC and specifying the terms and conditions of the trade.

Beneficiary

The seller who receives payment through the LC. They must present all required documents correctly to receive payment.

Issuing Bank

The bank that issues the LC on behalf of the applicant. They verify the buyer's creditworthiness and commit to making the payment when conditions are met.

Negotiating Bank

The negotiating bank in LC that examines documents presented by the beneficiary and facilitates payment. They ensure all paperwork matches LC requirements perfectly.

The process begins when the applicant approaches their issuing bank for an LC. The issuing bank then coordinates with the negotiating bank to establish terms and verify documents before releasing any funds.

Importance of Letters of Credit

Secure Payments

They ensure that sellers receive payments without requiring advance payments, reducing risk for both parties involved in the letter of credit.

Facilitate Cross-Border Transactions

LCs simplify complex international transactions by providing a standardised payment mechanism across different countries.

Secure Business Funding

They provide businesses with necessary funding while verifying creditworthiness, helping companies maintain healthy cash flow.

Financial Assurance

LCs offer security when buyers cannot pay, acting as a guarantee backed by reliable banking institutions.

Advantages of Letters of Credit

Ease International Trade: Simplifies complex transactions across borders by providing a structured framework for payment and documentation.

Foster Global Business Connections: Builds trust between trading partners by removing payment uncertainty and providing bank-backed guarantees.

Provide Flexibility: Customisable terms to suit various transaction needs, including payment timing, shipping requirements, and document presentation.

Parties to Documentary Credit

Commercial/Trade Parties: The buyer and seller form the core of the transaction, initiating and completing the trade deal.

Banks: Issuing and advising banks serve as intermediaries ensuring secure payment and proper documentation.

Related Entities: Shipping lines and insurers support the transaction by handling logistics and risk management aspects.

Types of a Letter of Credit

Sight Credit

A Sight Credit allows instant payment upon presenting the correct documents, providing immediate access to funds for sellers. For example, if a businessman needs quick access to cash after shipping goods, they can use this type of credit.

Acceptance Credit/Time Credit

Acceptance or Time Credit involves bills that are accepted upon presentation and paid on specified due dates. This type allows sellers to receive payments after a set period.

Revocable Letter of Credit

A Revocable Letter of Credit can be canceled or modified by the issuing bank without beneficiary consent, which limits its reliability in ensuring secure transactions.

Irrevocable Letter of Credit

An Irrevocable Letter of Credit guarantees payment once certified by the exporter’s bank. This type provides security for international transactions and is often preferred by exporters due to its reliability.

Confirmed Letter of Credit

A Confirmed Letter of Credit involves both issuing and confirming banks. The confirming bank guarantees payment to the beneficiary, holding equal liability as the issuing bank, ensuring that payments will be honored upon proper presentation.

Back-to-Back Letter of Credit

This type involves issuing a second LC based on the security provided by the first LC. It is commonly used to secure payments for suppliers in international trade transactions.

Transferable Letter of Credit

A Transferable Letter of Credit allows the primary beneficiary to transfer credit partially or fully to another beneficiary, typically a supplier. However, once transferred, the second beneficiary cannot transfer it further.

Restricted Letter of Credit

A Restricted Letter of Credit specifies a particular bank responsible for payment, limiting its scope compared to unrestricted LCs. This type is often used when specific banks are preferred due to their reliability.

Revolving Letter of Credit

A Revolving Letter of Credit allows reuse after payments or drawings are made. This flexibility is beneficial for businesses requiring multiple shipments or ongoing transactions under one credit arrangement.

Precautions to be Taken

Verify Bank Reliability: The issuing bank must be reliable and well-known to both parties of the letter of credit. This helps minimise risks and ensures the LC will be honored when presented.

Local Bank Verification: It's essential to advise through an Indian bank and confirm the authenticity of the LC. The local bank can verify the legitimacy of the foreign bank and ensure all documents meet local regulations.

Clarify Financial Terms: Make sure to clearly establish who covers all bank charges and confirm freight payment terms as specified in contract agreements. This prevents disputes and unexpected costs during the transaction process.

Import Export Code

The Import Export Code (IEC) is a mandatory document required for all businesses involved in international trade. This code streamlines customs clearance, enables duty benefits, and ensures regulatory compliance. Through platforms like Razorpay Rize, businesses can obtain their IEC within 6-7 days which makes the process efficient and straightforward.

Frequently Asked Questions