Do You Need a CA to Register a Company in India?

Difference Between Company and Partnership Firm

A company and partnership difference is rooted in their legal definitions and formation processes. A company is an incorporated entity under the Companies Act, 2013, with shareholders owning the business. Conversely, a partnership firm is an unincorporated association of individuals governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, where partners collectively own and manage the business.

Here's a table highlighting the main differences:

Looking to register your Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) effortlessly? Get started with Razorpay Rize today and streamline your business registration process!

Understanding a Company

Definition of Company

A company is a distinct legal entity formed by an association of people to carry on a business. The Indian Companies Act of 2013, Section 2(20), defines "company" as "a company incorporated under the Companies Act 2013 or any previous company law." Companies can be public or private, with private limited companies having 2-200 members and public companies having at least 7 members with no upper limit.

Types of Company

Here are the types of companies:

1. Private limited company: A privately held company with 2-200 members, where the transfer of shares is restricted.
2. Public limited company: A company that can invite the public to subscribe to its shares, with a minimum of 7 members and no upper limit.
3. One Person Company: A company with only one member.

Characteristics of a Company

• Separate legal entity
• Limited liability for members
• Perpetual succession
• Transferable shares
• Managed by Board of Directors
• Stringent compliance requirements

Company registration involves a formal process, including filing Memorandum and Articles of Association, obtaining DIN for directors, and submitting requisite documents to the Registrar of Companies.

Understanding a Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business structure where two or more partners come together to run a business collectively. The partners share the profits and bear the losses of the business in the agreed proportion.

Definition of Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business structure formed by an association of two or more people who agree to share business profits. The Indian Partnership Act of 1932, Section 4, defines Partnership as "The relation between persons who have agreed to share profits of business carried on by all or any of them acting for all."

Partnerships can be general partnerships where all partners have unlimited liability, or limited liability partnerships (LLPs) with both general and limited partners. The key differences between a company and partnership relate to legal structure, liability, management, ownership transfer, regulatory compliance, and taxation.

Characteristics of a Partnership Firm

• Formed by an agreement between partners
• No separate legal entity from partners
• Unlimited liability for partners
• Profit sharing as per partnership deed
• Jointly managed by partners
• Fewer compliance requirements compared to companies
• Ideal for small and medium-sized businesses

Similarities Between Company and Partnership Firm

Despite their difference between company and partnership firm, they share some common characteristics:

• Formed for carrying on a business
• Require registration with relevant authorities
• Aim to earn profits
• Governed by specific laws and regulations
• Require maintenance of books of accounts
• Can sue and be sued in their own name

Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between a company and a partnership depends on business goals, liability, taxation, and compliance requirements. Below are hypothetical examples to help you decide.

1. Business Size & Growth Potential

• Choose a Company: If you plan to scale your business, attract investors, or raise capital, a company structure is ideal.
  
  • Example: Raj and Meera start an AI-based edtech startup. They plan to raise funds from investors and expand globally. To do this, they register as a private limited company and issue shares to investors.
• Choose a Partnership: If you prefer a small-scale business with direct decision-making, a partnership is a better choice.
  
  • Example: Aarav and Kunal start a custom furniture workshop in their city. Since they don’t need external funding and want to split profits equally, they form a partnership firm.

2. Liability Protection

• Company: Offers limited liability, meaning the owners’ personal assets are protected in case of losses.
  
  • Example: Neha runs an organic skincare brand. A customer files a lawsuit over an allergic reaction. Since Neha's business is a registered company, her personal assets remain safe, and only the company’s assets are at risk.
• Partnership: In a general partnership, partners have unlimited liability, meaning personal assets can be used to settle business debts.
  
  • Example: Vikram and Ramesh own a small event management business. They take a loan for an event but incur heavy losses. As a partnership, both partners are personally responsible for repaying the loan, even if it means selling personal assets.

Note: In a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), personal liability is restricted.

3. Taxation Structure

• Company: Pays corporate tax, and profits distributed as dividends may be taxed separately.
  
  • Example: An IT consulting firm is structured as a private limited company. While it pays corporate tax, its owners benefit from lower tax rates on dividends compared to individual income tax.
• Partnership: Profits are taxed at the individual level, often leading to lower overall tax liability.
  
  • Example: A local bakery run by two partners is taxed based on individual earnings, avoiding corporate tax obligations and reducing overall tax liability.

4. Compliance & Legal Requirements

• Company: Requires mandatory registration, regular filings, audits, and compliance with corporate laws.
  
  • Example: A group of engineers launches a renewable energy startup. Since they have multiple stakeholders and need regulatory approvals, they register as a company, ensuring compliance with industry standards.
• Partnership: Has minimal legal requirements, making it easier and cost-effective to manage.
  
  • Example: A duo running a content writing agency operates as a partnership to avoid the hassle of extensive compliance, annual filings, and statutory audits.

5. Business Continuity & Stability

• Company: Has a separate legal identity, meaning the business continues even if owners change.
  
  • Example: A software firm registered as a company continues operations after one founder exits by transferring shares to a new investor.
• Partnership: Typically dissolves if a partner exits unless an agreement states otherwise.
  
  • Example: A law firm operating as a partnership dissolves after one partner retires, requiring a new agreement to continue operations.

In conclusion, understanding the difference between partnership and company is crucial for entrepreneurs when deciding on the most suitable business structure. While a Sole Proprietorship offers simplicity and control, a partnership firm enables collaboration and shared responsibility. On the other hand, a company, particularly a private limited company, provides limited liability and greater scalability. Consider factors such as liability, management, compliance, and growth prospects when choosing between a partnership vs company. Seek professional advice to make an informed decision aligned with your business objectives and risk appetite.

Frequently Asked Questions:

Benefits of USA Company Registration

It is highly advisable to go for U.S. incorporation when aiming to raise capital from U.S. investors or penetrate the U.S. market with product sales. Beyond the inherent credibility associated with a U.S. business entity, it instills investor confidence and aligns with U.S. regulatory expectations.

• It boasts a thriving and a diverse business ecosystem, providing access to a vast market, diverse consumer base, and a network of established businesses and startups.
• Companies incorporated in the U.S. often find it easier to attract investment, whether through venture capital, private equity, or public markets.
• It is home to renowned innovation hubs such as Silicon Valley, which fosters creativity, collaboration, and technological advancement. This can be especially beneficial for tech startups and businesses in emerging industries.
• It offers a relatively straightforward process for business incorporation. Many states, like Delaware, have business-friendly regulations and efficient online platforms that facilitate the setup and management of companies.
• While the U.S. tax system is complex, businesses may find advantages in various tax incentives and deductions, especially if structured as certain types of corporations.
• It can serve as a strategic base for international expansion, providing a gateway to both North American and global markets.

Types for Company Registration in USA from India

The United States offers several types of legal structures for businesses, each with its own characteristics and implications. Here are some of the most common types:

•  Single-Person Businesses

•  S Corporations

•  C- Corporations (C-Corp)

•  Limited Liability Companies (LLCs)

•  Non-profit Organizations

Regarding U.S. business structures, two predominant forms of incorporation stand out: Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) and C-Corporations (C-Corps). These structures offer distinct features tailored to diverse business needs and goals.

• If you want lower compliance and small franchise fees: An LLC may be a suitable choice, especially for small businesses or startups with simpler structures and a desire for reduced administrative burdens.
• If you want to raise funds: If the goal is to attract external investment, issue stock, or go public in the future, a C Corporation is often more attractive to investors and provides the necessary flexibility for these activities.

Minimum Requirements to register a company in the U.S.

To register a company in the U.S., several essential criteria must be met.

• Minimum Number of Individuals:
  At least one person is required to register a company in the U.S. This person can act as the sole owner or be part of a group of owners (members or shareholders), depending on the chosen business structure (e.g., LLC, corporation).
• Registered Agent in Delaware:
  If choosing to register the company in Delaware, having a registered agent in the state is a legal requirement. The registered agent is a person or entity designated to receive legal documents, official correspondence, and other important information on behalf of the company.
• U.S. Address:
  A U.S. address is required for official correspondence and legal purposes. This address can be either a physical location (such as a brick-and-mortar office) or a virtual address, depending on the nature of the business and the chosen state of registration.

Documents required for U.S. Incorporation

A succinct breakdown of the documents needed for the initial stages of business registration.

• Name Approval:
  The process for name approval is straightforward. In Delaware, you can perform a real-time search for the desired business name and immediately reserve it if available. This reservation ensures that your chosen business name is secured for your use.
• Director Details:
  Provide details about the directors or members of the company. This typically includes full names, addresses, contact information, and roles or titles within the company.
• Number of Shares and Value Per Share:
  Specify the number of authorized shares the company is allowed to issue. Also, determine the par value or the assigned value to each share.

Process for Company Registration in the USA

Must-Have Documents After Incorporation

Here’s a list of documents that a business typically receives after the registration process:

1. Certificate of Incorporation

• This document, issued by the state authorities, officially recognizes the establishment of the corporation. It includes important details such as the company's name, location, and date of incorporation.

2. EIN (Employer Identification Number)

• The EIN is a unique identifier assigned by the IRS for tax purposes. It typically takes 3 to 4 weeks through standard processing, but an expedited option is available, reducing the timeline to 3 days if you already possess a Social Security Number (SSN).
  This unique identifier, similar to India's PAN (Permanent Account Number), is necessary for various business activities, including opening a bank account, hiring employees, and filing tax returns.

3. Bylaws of the Company (Similar to Articles of Association)

• Bylaws are internal rules that govern the operation and management of the company. They outline procedures for meetings, decision-making, and other essential aspects of corporate governance.
  In some ways, they are similar to the Articles of Association mandated in India.

4. Banking Resolution

• A banking resolution is a formal document that authorizes specific individuals within the company to open and manage bank accounts on behalf of the corporation. It provides clarity and legal authority for banking-related activities.

5. Common Stock Certificate

• Common stock certificates represent ownership in the company. When shares are issued, these certificates are given to shareholders as evidence of their ownership stake in the corporation. They typically include details such as the shareholder's name, the number of shares, and the date of issuance.

Compliances for U.S.- Incorporated Companies

Let's dive into the detailed aspects of compliance for businesses in the US, particularly those with C-Corporation structures and operations in Delaware.

1. Federal Income Tax

• The Federal Income Tax rate of 21% applies to C-corporations in the United States. They are required to file a tax return annually using the IRS Form 1120. This form outlines the corporation's income, deductions, credits, and taxes owed, etc.

2. Withholding Tax and Related Party Transactions Disclosure

• Similar to Tax Deducted at Source (TDS), withholding Tax in the U.S. involves deducting a portion of payments made to non-residents for services, dividends, or interest. Additionally, disclosure of related party transactions is a key compliance requirement, ensuring transparency in financial dealings with affiliated entities.

3. Delaware State Franchise Tax

• Delaware imposes an annual franchise tax on corporations, and the amount varies depending on the type and size of the corporation. The calculation is often based on factors such as authorized shares or assumed par value capital.

4. Delaware State Corporate Income Tax

• In addition to federal taxes, C-Corporations operating within the state of Delaware are subject to state corporate income tax at a rate of 8.7% on income generated within the state.
  To meet state tax obligations, C-Corporations file the Delaware Form 1100, providing detailed information on income, deductions, and other relevant financial data.

5. Other Regulatory Compliances in Delaware

• Beyond tax-related obligations, businesses in Delaware must adhere to additional regulatory requirements. This includes filing an annual report with the Delaware Secretary of State.

In a nutshell, be it India or the U.S., there will be a lot of compliances to keep a record of. By diligently meeting these obligations, you can fulfill legal mandates and contribute to a robust and trustworthy business environment.

Incorporation in U.S. vs India

When expanding operations from India to the United States, a common strategy involves incorporating a new U.S. company, followed by transferring shares from the Indian parent company (which must be a Private Limited Company) to the newly formed U.S. entity. The Indian company would become a subsidiary of the U.S. company, and there is no such limit to the number of subsidiaries an entity can have.

Keep in mind the compliances and FEMA guidelines to be adhered to during this process, which establishes the U.S. company as a subsidiary of its Indian counterpart, creating a legal and financial separation. The benefits of this approach include improved access to U.S. markets, legal autonomy for each entity, and strategic financial advantages.

{{pvt-cta}}

*Prices and documents can differ based on the company type.

Format of a Partnership Deed

{{scroll-image}}

The format of a partnership deed may vary based on the specific requirements of the partners and the nature of the business. However, a typical partnership deed includes the following essential elements:

• Name of the Partnership:
  The official business name under which the partnership operates is stated, along with the physical address where the primary business activities occur. This section also highlights the duration of the partnership firm alongside the date of the commencement.
• Details of the Partners:
  This section includes the full name, address, and relevant particulars of the Individuals participating in the Partnership.
• Purpose:
  Here, the nature and scope of the business activities conducted by the partnership is clearly stated. The firm shall have the power to fulfill the objectives of thecompany and conduct any such lawful business activities.
• Capital Contribution:
  The total capital of the firm and the individual share contributed by each partner are to be mentioned here. The contribution can be in cash, goods, or property on agreed values.
• Profit and Loss Sharing:
  ‍It clearly articulates the agreed-upon ratio or percentage in which profits and losses will be distributed among the partners.
• Financial Decisions:
  It includes information such as the partners' salary and commission, permissive drawings from the firm for each partner, the interest payable to the firm on these drawings, partnership loans, and other relevant details.
• Admission and Retirement of Partners:
  ‍This part outlines the criteria and process for admitting new partners into the business. Similarly, it details the procedures for the retirement or withdrawal of existing partners.
• Dispute Resolution:
  Procedures for resolving disputes among partners are established. This may include mechanisms for mediation or arbitration to address conflicts and maintain a harmonious partnership.
• Dissolution:
  It states the conditions and procedures for the dissolution of the partnership which highlights the distribution of assets, settlement of liabilities, and the overall process of winding up the business.
• Witnesses and Signatures:
  The partnership deed is formally executed with the signatures of all partners, and done in the presence of witnesses.

How to draft a Partnership Deed?

A partnership deed can be a verbal or written agreement outlining the rights, responsibilities, profit-sharing, and other obligations of the partners.

While it can be recorded verbally, it is highly advisable to formalize a written partnership deed with the Registrar of Firms as it aids in resolving potential disputes. It also proves beneficial for tax purposes and ensures the formal registration of the partnership firm.

• The Partnership Deed, formulated by the partners, must be executed on stamp paper with a minimum value of Rs. 200, as per the Indian Stamp Act.
• Each partner should retain a copy of the partnership deed for future reference.
• Once stamped, the Partnership deed is attached with the application to the Registrar of Firms for formal registration and legal validation.

As per the Partnership Act, Registration of Partnership Firms is optional, but if you still choose to register your firm-

The application should be accompanied by essential documents, including a duly filled affidavit, a certified true copy of the Partnership Deed, and proof of ownership or a rental/lease agreement for the main business location.

Validity of the Partnership Deed

The validity of the firm is mentioned in the deed, whether it's for a limited period, for a specific project or for an unlimited period.

Note: A partnership deed that has been notarized alone does not hold legal validity in the event of legal disputes. However, if the partnership firm is formally registered with RoF, the partnership deed will be recognized as having legal standing.

Fees for the Partnership Deed in India

The Partnership Deed must be executed on a stamp paper with a minimum value of Rs. 200, as per the Indian Stamp Act.

However, Partnership registration fees vary among states due to different compliance requirements and stamp duty rates. The cost for registering a Partnership Firm ranges from Rs. 500 to Rs. 3000.

Note: Stamp duty is calculated based on partner contributions and follows state-specific regulations.

Alterations in the Partnership Deed

Partners have the flexibility to modify, alter, or change the partnership deed through mutual agreement. All partners are required to sign the amended deed.

Subsequently, the modified partnership deed should be registered at the Sub-Registrar's office, where the original deed was registered. Additionally, it is necessary to submit the modified deed to the Registrar of Firms for record-keeping purposes.

{{business-cta}}